Home / Food & Kitchen / Ninja CREAMi

Ninja CREAMi

PRICE$179-$229
RATING8.4 / 10
BEST FORPeople who meal-prep desserts and want control over sugar or protein content
WORTH IT, MOSTLY

The Ninja CREAMi is worth buying if you actually eat frozen desserts often enough to plan a day ahead, since the texture beats any blender-based method and lets you control every ingredient down to the sugar. Skip it if you want same-day cravings solved, because the mandatory 24-hour freeze is the one thing no setting or hack gets around.

PROS

  • Turns a frozen pint of Greek yogurt or milk into true soft-serve texture in under 5 minutes
  • Pint containers and lids are dishwasher-safe and stack flat in a standard freezer door
  • The Re-Spin function rescues a crumbly or icy batch without starting the freeze cycle over
  • Handles more than ice cream: sorbet, milkshakes, protein shakes, even frozen coffee drinks
  • Lets you cut sugar or dairy entirely, which matters if you're cooking for keto, diabetic, or lactose-free diets

CONS

  • Every batch needs a full 24 hours in the freezer first, so it's useless for a same-day craving
  • The motor is genuinely loud, more like a coffee grinder than a blender, for the full 1-2 minute spin cycle
  • Extra pint containers cost $15-20 for a 2-pack, and you'll want at least 4-6 in rotation to keep flavors going

I've put about 15 batches through my CREAMi over the last month, everything from a basic vanilla bean base to a peanut butter protein version made with whey powder and unsweetened almond milk. The first spin out of the freezer is genuinely rough, dense and crumbly like frozen concrete, and if you skip the Re-Spin step you'll think you wasted a pint. Hit Re-Spin once and it turns into something closer to actual soft-serve than I expected from a countertop machine that costs less than a KitchenAid attachment.

Where it earns its keep is control. My sister is doing keto and I made her a batch with heavy cream, monk fruit sweetener, and cocoa powder that came out richer than anything she can buy pre-made. That's the real selling point here, not novelty ice cream flavors but the ability to hit specific macros or avoid specific ingredients without sacrificing texture.

The planning requirement is the real tradeoff, though. I've forgotten to freeze a base more times than I'd like to admit, which means no dessert that night regardless of how badly I wanted one. And once you own more than 2 pints, you're looking at real freezer real estate, mine currently has 5 pints in permanent rotation plus the ice cream itself once it's spun.

At $179 for the basic Deluxe model or up to $229 for versions with extra pints and mix-in paddles, it's not cheap, but I've used mine at least twice a week since I got it, which is more than I can say for most kitchen gadgets past month one. If you actually eat frozen dessert regularly and hate what's in store-bought pints, this earns its cabinet space.

← Back to Food & Kitchen reviews

Rachel Reviews may earn a commission from links on this site.
That never changes which products get covered or how they're rated.
See the methodology. © 2026.